Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

Google

  • Google
    Google

    WWW
    www.mbpalaver.com

« ArtPalaver: Annie and Ansel at the Corcoran | Main | SportsPalaver: Plexicushion Down Under »

January 13, 2008

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

contessa

Wasn't there a lot of running around the streets of Bath in this version, not to mention people dashing out of the concert hall? I don't recall quite so much vigorous exertion in Jane Austin ... but then I haven't committed the Amanda Root/Ciaran Hinds version to memory (like some people).

mbpalaver

I agree there was an unseemly amount of rushing, jogging, and chasing. How about that scene where the camera was chasing Anne and her friend down the street from behind? I found the Root/Hinds version much quieter and intense, and thought the payoff there was much more dramatic (though I can't comment on which was more true to the book, as I haven't read in many years).

mysterywriter

It's been about ten years since I read Persuasion, but I remember thinking that the Root/Hinds version was very true to it. That being said, in some editions of the book, Jane gives an alternate ending as well, which--though you still get the ultimate ending you want--is very anti-climatic.

The comments to this entry are closed.

Blog powered by Typepad